Some employers use benefit tiers for exempt and nonexempt staff
By Stephen Miller, CEBS

SHRM | October 08, 2019

Overtime Rule

Employers complying with the Department of Labor’s final rule raising the salary threshold for time-and-a-half overtime pay to $35,568, up from $23,660, should consider the effect the new requirements may have on their employee benefit plans.

Some employers have different benefit tiers for salaried/exempt and hourly/nonexempt workers, or use exempt and nonexempt status to determine benefit eligibility and contribution levels, noted Kathryn Wheeler, an attorney with law firm Jackson Lewis P.C.’s employee benefits practice group in Overland Park, Kan. That could present challenges as some employees who were exempt from overtime pay are reclassified as nonexempt, while others receive pay hikes to keep their exempt status.

What happens, for instance, when a currently exempt employee, participating in benefit plans limited to salaried workers, makes $475 a week in 2019? Starting in January, that employee, still making $475 a week, becomes a nonexempt employee and is no longer eligible for the same benefit plans, Wheeler explained.

For employer-sponsored retirement plans, “the effects of employees shifting from one plan to another effective Jan. 1, 2020, could create issues with nondiscrimination testing, top-heavy results or a reduction in certain benefits going forward, which may require advance notice to the affected participants,” she advised. Annual nondiscrimination testing, for instance, is meant to ensure that plans do not discriminate in favor of highly compensated employees. A plan is top heavy when the total value of the plan accounts of key employees is more than 60 percent of the total value of the plan assets.

Retirement Plan Issues

Employers will likely have to make larger retirement plan contributions if their plan uses a definition of compensation that includes overtime pay, benefits specialists advised. Alternatively, if the employer’s plan excludes overtime for calculating contributions, employers will have to pay closer attention to nondiscrimination testing results.

Consultants at HR advisory firm Mercer noted, “If retirement plan sponsors pay more overtime to more employees, both defined-benefit and defined-contribution plans that recognize overtime in their definition of earnings may see increased costs.” Katharine Marshall, Margaret Berger and Brian Kearney, members of Mercer’s law and policy group, gave the following examples of the possible impact of the new law on 401(k) and other defined-contribution plans.

  • Matching contributions. For plans that recognize overtime pay when calculating employer contributions, “a 10 percent increase in earnings will generally produce a 10 percent increase in elective deferrals and matching and other employer contributions,” the consultants pointed out, although “the exact cost impact will depend on the employee’s deferral rate and the plan’s contribution formula.”
  • Nondiscrimination testing. The accrual rates and deferral/contribution percentages of plan participants who are not highly compensated may fall if the plan excludes overtime from the pay used to determine benefits but includes overtime in the pay used for nondiscrimination testing. “Since highly compensated employees’ accrual rates and deferral/contribution percentages won’t be affected,” the consultants noted, “the overall testing results may suffer,” causing more plans to fail the test.
  • Pension plans. For defined-benefit pensions, “the cost increase will depend on the underlying plan formula and the plan’s funded status. A 10 percent increase in affected employees’ earnings won’t necessarily lead to a 10 percent increase in pension costs for those employees,” Marshall, Berger and Kearney noted. “For well-funded [defined-benefit] plans, the Internal Revenue Code’s funding requirements may mean the immediate cost impact might even be zero.”

Health Plans and Other Benefits

As some currently exempt employees are reclassified as nonexempt, “employers should check to see if eligibility for any health or fringe benefits (such as adoption or education assistance, employee discount programs, or group term life insurance) is conditioned on an employee’s exempt or nonexempt status,” Marshall, Berger and Kearney wrote. “A change in the population of eligible employees for any particular benefit could affect its cost and effectiveness.”

Complying with the Raised Threshold

Employers should have a plan of action for the new overtime pay threshold, advised Lakshmi Raj, co-founder and co-CEO at enterprise time and attendance software firm Replicon. She recommends that employers take these measures before the new year:

  • Assess the current situation. Look at the way things are now and then make an action plan. Who will remain exempt, and who will make the switch?
  • Inform employees about all changing policies. Keep communication open and accessible between employer and employee before, during and after the transition. Concerns affecting morale, compensation and status should be addressed readily and transparently.
  • Monitor all employee hours. Insight can be gleaned from tracking employee hours, including exempt employees. This can support, clarify and inform businesses on any wage and hour hiccups down the line.
  • Maintain compliance by reviewing state laws. Many states have higher thresholds and additional criteria for exempt status than under federal law. Note these in detail, verifying compliance and ensuring overtime hours are correctly measured.

Original Source: SHRM
Author: Stephen Miller, CEBS

Get started today.
Set up a free trial based on your business needs. Start Free Trial

Want Real Solutions That Help You Manage Expense Tracking in Real-Time? We’ve Got Them.

A comprehensive expense tracker can provide your organization with clear insights into how corporate time and dollars are being spent and help you identify unnecessary costs, strains, time-wasting activities, and…Read More

Project Leaders: Here Are 3 Signs Your Remote Project Managers Are Overwhelmed with Technology

Overwhelmed project managers. They are not hard to find. And if you look closely, you’ll probably find a few right within your organization. As it is, project management is stressful…Read More

5 Questions to Ask When Evaluating and Purchasing New Time Tracking Software for Your Enterprise

Time. Regardless of how well your organization performs year over year, time is one thing that you can’t order more of. There are no do-overs, no second chances, and no…Read More

Consulting firms: 4 ways to improve billing & get paid on time

At the end of the day, your consulting firm relies on the assumption that a good percentage of clients will honor their payments promptly and accurately. In the professional services…Read More

5 Ways to Improve Service Delivery in Your Organization

In a highly competitive market, service-based businesses need to capitalize on any opportunity to set themselves apart from their (often very similar) competitors. While implementation, system details, and service management…Read More

Demystifying the millennial workforce: 5 tips from Trunk Club’s Andrew Anderson Devine

Time magazine labels the millennial generation the “most threatening and exciting generation,” infamous for “narcissism [and] its effect: entitlement.” In the workplace, the perception of the millennial workforce is no…Read More
  • Polaris
  • Time & Project Insights
  • Time & Projects Solutions
  • Replicon Products
  • Replicon Users
  • Cloud
  • Corporate
  • Professional Services Management
  • Shared Services Management
  • Time and Attendance Management
  • Customer Feature
  • Time Intelligence
  • Industry News
  • Global Compliance Updates