Global Compliance Desk – New Zealand

Judgment Relating to Employee Commissions and Holiday pay 

Recently, New Zealand’s Employment Court gave transparency to an earlier untested area of the Holidays Act. In the case of, Tourism Holdings Limited v A Labour Inspector of the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment [2019] NZ Emp C 87, the Employment Court examined how the definition of ordinary weekly pay demands an employer to treat commissions when calculating holiday pay.

As per the Holidays Act, when an employee takes a paid annual holiday, they are entitled to be paid the greater of their:

  • Ordinary weekly pay; or
  • Average weekly earnings for the previous 12 months (starting from their last pay period).

Ordinary weekly pay includes productivity or incentive-based payments (such as commission) which are a “regular part of the employee’s pay”. This case was mainly concerned with these words – “a regular part of the employee’s pay”.

Case Brief

Tourism Holdings employs bus drivers, who earn commission on the sale of activities they book for passengers. The dispute between the Labour Inspector and Tourism Holdings concerned whether commissions earned in this manner should be considered a ‘regular part’ of the drivers’ pay for an ordinary working week. The company says the drivers’ commissions are not to be included in the calculation under, because the amount earned in this way is not a “regular part” of her pay for an ordinary working week. If they are a ‘regular part’ of the driver’s pay, they are required to be included when calculating holiday pay.

Tourism Holdings argued that commissions earned by drivers were excluded from the statutory definition of ‘ordinary weekly pay’, and said that the definition was intended to apply to what the driver was entitled to under the employment agreement for that ordinary working week and that did not apply to the commission which was earned in a different way.

The Labour Inspector argued that:

  • The drivers are ‘regularly’ paid commissions earned on trips;
  • That no period of time is expressly given in the Holidays Act against which the regularity of commission payments can be measured; and
  • That Parliamentary intention, and a ‘balanced and harmonious approach to the formula” was a period of at least 4 weeks when considering commissions earned.

Conclusion

The Employment Court held that the designed meaning of ‘regular’ within the Act is what is received under the employment agreement for an ordinary working week.  The word “regular” used in the particular subsections is not defined in the Act and could give rise to ambiguity.

What is regular could be those items of pay routinely or commonly featuring in the employee’s pay regardless of when they were earned, or those items that are earned and have become payable under the employment agreement during the working week.

The text of the particular section defining “ordinary rates of pay” indicates that what is to be ascertained is the employee’s ordinary weekly pay for an ordinary working week so that holiday pay can be calculated and paid. What is to be included, and excluded, from that calculation is designed to enable a calculation representative of an ordinary working week. Commonly “regular” can mean systematic, or something acting or done or recurring, uniformly. Tourism Holdings’ drivers commonly received pay including commission, but that was earned over varying intervals of time and required reconciliation after each trip (which could extend well beyond a week), and as such did not constitute the ‘regular’ type of payment contemplated by the Act. 

Thus, it was decided and agreed by the employment court that, it was not required under the terms of this driver’s employment agreement, and by the operation of s 8(2) of the Act, to include in the calculation of her ordinary weekly pay commission payments received by her during the four-week period preceding her annual holiday. 

Shreya Bhattacharya
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Shreya Bhattacharya
A labor and employment lawyer at Replicon who specializes in global compliance. Replicon provides award-winning products that make it easy to manage your workforce. Replicon is an industry leader in global compliance and has a dedicated team which pro-actively monitors international labor regulations for ensuring proper adherence with specific country rule requirements.
Get started today.
Set up a free trial based on your business needs. Start Free Trial

Common Administrative Challenges with Timesheets and How to Solve Them

There aren’t many people who enjoy sifting through a mountain of paperwork. If you haven’t yet found a reliable time tracking software solution, dealing with the hassle and headache of…Read More

How a Shared Common Data Platform for Project Management Can Create Harmony Across Business Teams

Today, professional services firms use some combination of ERP, CRM, HRIS, PPM, or other software along with their PSA solution. These systems serve different purposes, host different and overlapping data,…Read More

6 Ways to Simplify Remote Resource Allocation and Why It Matters

When you’re an enterprise operating at a global scale with a team of employees working from home, one of your major concerns is proper resource allocation. When it goes wrong,…Read More

Will AI replace consultants?

The onset of AI and smart machines automating formerly-human jobs has been discussed at length as of late -- often in relation to manufacturing and manual labor jobs. And yet,…Read More

6 steps for fast-tracking profitability in your consulting practice

Advice aimed at entrepreneurs and small businesses tends to be heavily product-oriented, but in reality the majority of US small businesses fall under the “Professional, Scientific, Technical, and Other Services”…Read More

Consulting firms: 4 ways to improve billing & get paid on time

At the end of the day, your consulting firm relies on the assumption that a good percentage of clients will honor their payments promptly and accurately. In the professional services…Read More
  • Polaris
  • Time & Project Insights
  • Time & Projects Solutions
  • Replicon Products
  • Replicon Users
  • Cloud
  • Corporate
  • Professional Services Management
  • Shared Services Management
  • Time and Attendance Management
  • Customer Feature
  • Time Intelligence
  • Industry News
  • Global Compliance Updates